Property Valuations Reservoir
Property Valuations Reservoir
Order a valuation
Property Valuations Reservoir

Comparing an older Reservoir house with a newer townhouse

A new townhouse can sell close to an older detached house while offering less land and a more recent fit-out. The similar price does not mean the two properties have the same strengths or that one sale can be copied across to the other.

In Reservoir, a useful comparison starts with what the buyer actually acquired: the land interest, usable accommodation, condition and everyday access.

Look past the bedroom count

Three bedrooms can fit into very different homes. An older house may have rooms opening from a central hallway, a separate living area and a large rear garden. A townhouse may offer newer bathrooms but more stairs and less space around the building.

The layout matters because floor area alone does not describe how a home works. A ground-floor bedroom, storage, natural light and the position of bathrooms can change which buyers find it suitable.

Record the actual accommodation and its condition. Marketing photographs may not show a narrow garage, steep stairs or an addition that needs work. A recently repainted room is also different from a documented structural repair.

Know which land belongs to the property

A detached home on its own parcel and a townhouse sharing access can involve different ownership arrangements. Read the title and plan before assuming a courtyard, parking space or driveway forms part of the private lot.

A generous outdoor area may be attractive, but its value depends on its usefulness as well as its size. Shape, privacy, access and the building's position all influence what the owner can do with it.

For a hypothetical example, a rear townhouse with convenient parking and a private garden may suit one buyer better than a larger front yard beside a busy street. That preference needs market evidence; a simple rate per square metre cannot settle it.

Check the local setting in detail

Darebin's Reservoir Streetscape Master Plan discusses the relationship between Broadway, Edwardes Street and the station precinct. It provides useful context for looking closely at access, rather than treating the whole suburb as one identical location.

Measure the practical route from each property to the places a buyer is likely to use. A straight-line distance can hide a difficult crossing or an indirect walk. Street traffic and the home's position on the site also deserve attention.

The Reservoir Structure Plan is background to the centre's planning history. It should not be used as a promise that a particular improvement will occur or that a house can be redeveloped. Check current controls for the exact address.

Choose evidence that explains the difference

Start with recent sales of properties that offer similar choices to buyers. Detached-house sales will often be more informative for another detached house, while townhouse sales can help describe the alternatives in the market.

Sometimes the best available evidence includes both. The task then is to explain the differences instead of averaging the prices. An older home needing major work should not be treated as renovated simply because its floor area matches a polished townhouse.

For a Reservoir property valuation, provide the title plan, floor plan and records of substantial work. Through the contact page, flag any shared-access or ownership question early. Include details of substantial repairs and the dates of extensions where these help explain the condition being assessed.